Public comparison report

PA12 Material Family Comparison

3DPIceland Labs
Generated with 3DPIceland Engineering Platform v70.0.4 DIRECT-IMPACT-METHODOLOGY - Izod and Charpy Methodology
2026-10-04 18:10:00

Public-data contract: only explicitly allowlisted MaterialIDs and existing Verified Material Summary scores are included. No measurements or scores are recalculated.

Comparison scope: Stable Material Family preset for PA12. Every included MaterialID has explicit Public reports opt-in.

Materials compared

Overall score available

All 8 axes available

Engineering-axis leaders in this comparison

Axis	Leading material	Score
Overall	BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black	48
Tensile	Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black	43
Impact	—	n/a
Izod	Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black	23
Charpy	Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black	24
Stiffness	Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black	89
Consistency	MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black	88
Layer adhesion	Fillamentum FX256 PA12 Clear	54
Thermal	Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black	80

Overall comparison

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

48/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

48/100

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

43/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

41/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

39/100

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

34/100

Tensile comparison

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

43/100

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

39/100

Extrudr DuraPro PA12 Black

34/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

33/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

33/100

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

32/100

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

28/100

Fillamentum FX256 PA12 Clear

28/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 Black

22/100

Izod comparison

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

23/100

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

21/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

19/100

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

11/100

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

10/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

5/100

Charpy comparison

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

24/100

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

22/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

20/100

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

11/100

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

11/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

6/100

Stiffness comparison

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

89/100

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

87/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

64/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

56/100

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

50/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 Black

44/100

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

37/100

Extrudr DuraPro PA12 Black

37/100

Fillamentum FX256 PA12 Clear

26/100

Thermal comparison

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

80/100

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

68/100

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

66/100

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

60/100

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

54/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

53/100

Yasin Standard Black PA12 Black

50/100

Extrudr DuraPro PA12 Black

42/100

Fillamentum FX256 PA12 Clear

33/100

Materials and evidence context

MaterialID	Material	Manufacturer	Product line	Type	Reinforcement	Rigid test coverage	Engineering axes
MAT0167	BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black	BambuLab	Basic	PA12	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8
MAT0214	Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black	Eryone	Standard	PA12	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8
MAT0019	MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black	MatterHackers	NylonX	PA12	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8
MAT0209	Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black	Eryone	Standard	PA12	GF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8
MAT0239	Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black	Yasin	Standard	PA12	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8
MAT0196	Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black	Extrudr	DuraPro	PA12	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8
MAT0020	Extrudr DuraPro PA12 Black	Extrudr	DuraPro	PA12		Partial; 4/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 0/2 measured, 0/2 scored; Overall unavailable: missing measurements or references; policy engineering-score-v70-1	5/8
MAT0022	Fillamentum FX256 PA12 Clear	Fillamentum	FX256	PA12		Partial; 4/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 0/2 measured, 0/2 scored; Overall unavailable: missing measurements or references; policy engineering-score-v70-1	5/8
MAT0021	Yasin Standard Black PA12 Black	Yasin	Standard	PA12		Partial; 4/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 0/2 measured, 0/2 scored; Overall unavailable: missing measurements or references; policy engineering-score-v70-1	5/8

Side-by-side engineering scores

MaterialID	Material	Manufacturer	Reinforcement	Rigid coverage	Evidence	Overall	Tensile	Impact	Izod	Charpy	Stiffness	Consistency	Layer adhesion	Thermal	Fixture °C	Method	Thermal limitation	MSRP USD/kg
MAT0167	BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black	BambuLab	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8	48/100	39/100	—	21/100	22/100	87/100	82/100	9/100	68/100	136 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$159.84
MAT0214	Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black	Eryone	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8	48/100	43/100	—	19/100	20/100	89/100	81/100	7/100	80/100	160 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$58.13
MAT0019	MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black	MatterHackers	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8	43/100	32/100	—	11/100	11/100	50/100	88/100	33/100	66/100	131 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$126.00
MAT0209	Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black	Eryone	GF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8	41/100	33/100	—	23/100	24/100	56/100	81/100	10/100	60/100	120 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$40.00
MAT0239	Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black	Yasin	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8	39/100	33/100	—	5/100	6/100	64/100	85/100	7/100	53/100	105 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$64.48
MAT0196	Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black	Extrudr	CF	Complete; 5/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 2/2 measured, 2/2 scored; Overall eligible; policy engineering-score-v70-1	7/8	34/100	28/100	—	10/100	11/100	37/100	79/100	16/100	54/100	107 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$76.06
MAT0020	Extrudr DuraPro PA12 Black	Extrudr		Partial; 4/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 0/2 measured, 0/2 scored; Overall unavailable: missing measurements or references; policy engineering-score-v70-1	5/8	—	34/100	—	—	—	37/100	83/100	43/100	42/100	84 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$49.80
MAT0022	Fillamentum FX256 PA12 Clear	Fillamentum		Partial; 4/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 0/2 measured, 0/2 scored; Overall unavailable: missing measurements or references; policy engineering-score-v70-1	5/8	—	28/100	—	—	—	26/100	80/100	54/100	33/100	65 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$46.74
MAT0021	Yasin Standard Black PA12 Black	Yasin		Partial; 4/5 score families; Izod/Charpy 0/2 measured, 0/2 scored; Overall unavailable: missing measurements or references; policy engineering-score-v70-1	5/8	—	22/100	—	—	—	44/100	67/100	9/100	50/100	99 °C	3dp-thermal-deflection-fixture-v1	Nearby BlueDOT probe-indicated fixture temperature from a non-standard comparative 3DPIceland method; not ASTM D648, ISO 75, specimen temperature, certified HDT or a manufacturer limit.	$53.12

Results are comparative 3DPIceland measurements and do not replace manufacturer datasheets or accredited laboratory testing.

Testing methodology · Engineering methodology whitepaper · Download PDF

BambuLab Basic PA12 PAHT CF Black

Izod and Charpy Impact Strength

Charpy Impact Strength · 2026-10-04
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 17.214 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.625 kJ/m²; CV 3.632%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Izod Impact Strength · 2026-10-04
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 16.462 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.508 kJ/m²; CV 3.085%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Eryone Standard Black PA12 CF Black

Izod and Charpy Impact Strength

Izod Impact Strength · 2026-10-01
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 14.986 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.641 kJ/m²; CV 4.274%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Charpy Impact Strength · 2026-10-01
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 16.137 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 1.031 kJ/m²; CV 6.387%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

MatterHackers NylonX PA12 CF Black

Izod and Charpy Impact Strength

Izod Impact Strength · 2026-10-04
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 8.907 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.604 kJ/m²; CV 6.785%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Charpy Impact Strength · 2026-10-04
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 8.674 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.792 kJ/m²; CV 9.135%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Eryone Standard Black PA12 GF Black

Izod and Charpy Impact Strength

Izod Impact Strength · 2026-09-30
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 18.772 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.281 kJ/m²; CV 1.495%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Charpy Impact Strength · 2026-09-30
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 19.057 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.964 kJ/m²; CV 5.057%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Yasin Standard Black PA12 CF Black

Izod and Charpy Impact Strength

Izod Impact Strength · 2026-10-04
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 4.373 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.127 kJ/m²; CV 2.91%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Charpy Impact Strength · 2026-10-04
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 4.7 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.44 kJ/m²; CV 9.353%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Extrudr DuraPro Black PA12 CF Black

Izod and Charpy Impact Strength

Izod Impact Strength · 2026-09-29
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 8.161 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.209 kJ/m²; CV 2.563%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Charpy Impact Strength · 2026-09-29
Instrument readings in kJ/m²
Mean 8.556 kJ/m²; Std. Dev 0.258 kJ/m²; CV 3.019%; Samples 10; Confidence 10
No break 0; invalid 0; excluded 0.
Comparative measurements; standard conformity unverified.

Score policy engineering-score-v70-1: Overall requires tensile, stiffness, consistency, layer adhesion and the Izod/Charpy impact family, each with equal weight. Both impact methods and configured versioned references are required. Missing results and unconfigured scores remain n/a. Legacy Impact is historical only; thermal remains separate. Engineering-axis counts describe displayed evidence, not Overall completeness.